Donald MacLennan was the half brother of GS McLennan, legendary 'piper, composer and important teacher.
The tune was clearly written to exercise strikes, and this is the main, but not only, thing to work on here.
The tune has a strange effect - it is not obvious to begin with, but as
you become more familiar with it, it will become ever easier to
remember, and ever more interesting.
You can make satisfaction from this tune in two opposite ways, and so keep it fresh and alive every time you play it.
One way is to look for the effect of trance, by keeping the rhythm strict and the gracenotes as equal as possible.
The opposite is to mark out hidden melodies by slightly emphasising
some notes over others This is achieved through pauses after notes
preceding the one you want to emphaise, bigger (slower) gracenotes onto
the notes to be emphasised and stretching notes that are emphasised.
Tips and practice points
1 Listen very carefully to the strikes in the slow versions. They are
all essentially the same length and take up a quarter of the preceding
note, opening on the beat or sub-beat
2 The doublings are also exceedingly light and fast. This is necessary
to prevent the tune from becoming a big blob of gracenotes.
3 The scary embellishments in the fifth and sixth parts are not as bad
as they seem. They are essentially the same rhythmical effect as each
other and this gives us confidence in the intepretation we can select
(there are many other wasy to handle this).
4 For the 'dare' in bar 17 the first F to be sounded is followed by an
E that is cut into two parts half the length of the first F. Where is a
high G gracenote before this embellishment later (bars 21 and 23) this
gracenote closes on the beat, thus making the F the point of the beat.
5 For the 'edre' with the high G gracenote, the same rhythmical pattern
as for the 'dare' should be used. Tis requires a lot of exercising to
make the F finger cut the low As very lightly and precisely.