Mrs Baillie of Dochfour
Composed by Pipe Major John Cameron, 3rd Cameron Highlanders
Strathspey
Discussion Points
1 This is a tune
that is published in the Edinburgh Collection by Glen. It appears there
with some very interesting rhythmical points, which have in part been
presented here. A photo of the historical source is at the bottom of
the page.
2 The birls are notated here as full notes with gracenotes,
as this is one of the most striking points from the Edinburgh
Collection publication. This represents a style of playing and is
actually much easier to create than it looks. Rather than thinking of a
birl as a single movement with one way of being performed, try thinking
of it as it is given here, in different rhythmical interpretations. As
ever, listen carefully to the videos, and this will make it much easier
too.
3 The bubbly note, or 'darodo' has a relatively long low G
prior to slicing into it at the start of the beat with the D gracenote.
Here it is the same length as the low A in every case. The historical
notation treats the D and C gracenotes as full notes, and the
rhythmical interpretation here reflects that, with the gracenotes
opening on the beat and subdivision accordingly. This is in contrast to
the very common approach of closing gracenotes on the beat or
subdivision.
4 The triplets have bee rendered as triplets. The
notation was not made by illiterate people, and it is very likely that
this is genuinely what was being played and what was intended by the
composer. Even if it isn't, it is a thrilling way to keep you audience
engaged and interested, and is truly beautiful to be able to realise.
5 All the high G gracenotes are given here as very short;
in the triplets there is one length, and otherwise there is just one
other. You will only be able to hear this in the very slow videos, but
the recipe is quite simple - outside of triplets all High G gracenotes
have five tails (1 two-hundred-and-fifty-sixth note). You may wish to
stretch some of them at the beginning of some bars.
6 The 'double tachum' C doublings to low A with an E
gracenote are very crisp, and the D and E gracenotes are the same
length as each other.You should try to create the sensation that you do
not stop on C.
7 The C doublings in bar 1 would often be treated as a
double tachum in modern editions. But here, it makes sense musically to
give the dots as first published, and this adds shape and interest to
your interpretation.
8 F doubling followed by E in bar 2 is another opportunity
for crafting the performed rhythm. This gives high contrast with the
number of different rhythmical figures adding a great deal to the tune.
9 Bar 10 also has an interesting rhythmical trick, worth paying attention to.
Videos to play along with - exercises below
Low pitch normal speed
Low pitch half speed
Low pitch quarter speed
High pitch normal speed
High pitch half speed
High pitch quarter speed
Exercises to help - click on the links for more information and videos to play along with